Depends on what the goal is.

Originally this was presented as having a goal of shifting the language usage in the culture at-large.

OK, so we come up with one example ("killing it"), and then it turns out that the example may have been appropriated from the African American community: uh-oh, if we go after that example it may appear that a bunch of nerds (conventionally thought of as white) are engaging in some kind of outsider-critique of someone else's community (black). 

That would be a mess, but we don't even have to go there: we have examples in our own subculture such as "killer app," and I'm suggesting we clean up our own house first by going after those.

Analogy: Violence in media.  "Violent lyrics in rap music!" Uh-oh, same uh-oh as with "killing it."  Contrast to "violence in video games," which does _not_ have potential implications involving race.

We have enough mess to clean up in our own back yard before we have any reasonable basis to venture forth into others' back yards where we might be seen as busybodies or worse. 

The place where that principle does not apply is when one community is under attack from members of another: for example where racism or discrimination are occurring, the targeted minority has every right to counterattack the culture of the attacking majority.  But that's not occurring here.

The additional issue, which wasn't the original issue behind "cuddling it" (or "cuddler app" for that matter;-) is cultural appropriation. 

Each of these is a distinct issue, with connections to other issues, but there's a difference between recognizing those connections vs. lumping all of it together to the point where nothing can be done.

Re. Anthony:

Anthony gets the award for "most-compact elucidation of a large & complex dynamic" for his item, "...(the) existential struggle among companies to achieve a position of oligarch in a crony capitalist market by killing off the competition once and for all and salting the earth they ate from with regulations and collusions so nothing will ever grow there again."

Oligarchy & crony capitalism:  One thing we _really really need to deal with_ is economic class.  There has been, in the Bay Area, an undercurrent of tension between "proletariat" and "lumpenproletariat" worldviews, and the analysis of the potential nexes of social change that follows.  This also deserves its own topic. 

Salting the Earth so nothing will grow:  This one is also huge, and it has some truly vicious implications for things we commonly interact with, and the attached political & economic realities.  And it's an additional issue that deserves its own topic. 

So, with that, it's time to start a couple more threads.

-G.

 



On 13-05-03-Fri 5:39 PM, mattsenate@gmail.com wrote:
But not to be lost in the discussion, and, in fact, most critical, is the value in multitudes, in variance, and in solidarity, based upon empathy and mutual understanding. This in resistance to dominant patterns of division and subsequent conquest. Therefore I claim scrutiny over cultural and linguistic appropriation remains relevant and crucial to recognize in context of mutual respect rather than a laissez-faire attitude.

What I mean is, let's try not to muddle it, but certainly cuddle it.

// Matt

----- Reply message -----
From: "Anthony Di Franco" <di.franco@gmail.com>
To: "GtwoG PublicOhOne" <g2g-public01@att.net>
Cc: ",sudo-discuss" <sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.org>
Subject: [sudo-discuss] cuddling it
Date: Fri, May 3, 2013 5:19 PM


That is all quite interesting and adds a lot of texture to the discussion.

And so is the question of the phrase "killer app" interesting. Consonant with an existential struggle among companies to achieve a position of oligarch in a crony capitalist market by killing off the competition once and for all and salting the earth they ate from with regulations and collusions so nothing will ever grow there again.

Though, I don't know how to limit things to a subculture supposed to be our own since we are all part of and relate to many different cultures, without necessarily any universal common thread, and the idea of creating fiefdoms of discourse based on arbitrary dualistic in-group-out-group distinctions is unappealing anyway.


On Fri, May 3, 2013 at 4:53 PM, GtwoG PublicOhOne <g2g-public01@att.net> wrote:

Yo's-

None the less, useful to explore.

As I understand the history of this: 

The word "savage" is the English adaptation of the French word "sauvage" that originally meant "forest-dweller."  At the time of early European settlement in North America, the practice in Europe was that only members of the nobility had the privilege of hunting in the forests: "commoners" (that would be us) were forbidden from doing so, often under penalty of death.

The Europeans who settled in North America were highly surprised to see that no such restriction existed among the Native peoples: any and all tribe members hunted freely in the woods. 

The phrase "noble savage" originally referred to this: the idea that ordinary tribe members had what in Europe was a special privilege of the nobility, the freedom to hunt in the woods.  The European settlers envied the First Nations peoples for having a privilege that they themselves did not have.

The dynamic is quite real to this day, of city-dwellers' envy of rural peoples, and industrial-culture peoples' envy of hunter-gatherer peoples.  It's a generalization of "the grass is always greener in the other person's yard."  It works both ways: every axis of contrast between someone's own circumstances and someone else's circumstances can become grounds for comparisons that may risk turning invidious in some way.  And once that process gets started, it opens the door to all manner of psychodynamic smog. 

So about "killing it":

Seems to me that if we're concerned about (whatever issue), and we run across examples that may be entangled with racial/ethnic/religious/gender/etc. issues, the best thing to do is to stick to examples that come squarely from within our own subculture. 

And what's the most frequent example of embedded violent language in geek/nerd/maker/hacker culture?

How'bout "killer app"?  Let's start with that one.

-G.

(Back under the correct address now; thanks to all who helped fix that.)




On 13-05-03-Fri 3:18 PM, Anthony Di Franco wrote:
No worries. My response was a rhetorical answer.


On Fri, May 3, 2013 at 3:16 PM, netdiva <netdiva@sonic.net> wrote:
Dont worry, that was really just a rhetorical question.


On 5/3/2013 3:11 PM, Anthony Di Franco wrote:
Of course.



On Fri, May 3, 2013 at 3:08 PM, netdiva <netdiva@sonic.net <mailto:netdiva@sonic.net>> wrote:

    Did you actually just say this in public?


    On 5/3/2013 3:04 PM, Anthony Di Franco wrote:

        Doesn't the civilized psyche secretly crave the things it sets itself
        apart from and gives up and projects on its image of the noble savage
        though?

        Your description seems more like meditatively flowing through it.


        On Fri, May 3, 2013 at 2:58 PM, netdiva <netdiva@sonic.net <mailto:netdiva@sonic.net>
        <mailto:netdiva@sonic.net <mailto:netdiva@sonic.net>>> wrote:

        Here I was thinking "killing it" was just another example of
        appropriation of african american vernacular by the mainstream.




        On 5/3/2013 2:46 PM, Leonid Kozhukh wrote:

        "killing it" is a recently popular term to denote excellence and
        immense progress. it has a violent, forceful connotation.

        friends in the circus community - through empirical evidence - have
        established a belief that operating at the highest levels of talent
        requires mindfulness, awareness, and calm. thus, a better term, which
        they have started to playfully use, is "cuddling it."

        thought sudoers would appreciate this.

        cuddling it,

        -- len

        founder, ligertail http://ligertail.com


        ___________________________________________________ sudo-discuss
        mailing list sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.____org
        <mailto:sudo-discuss@lists.__sudoroom.org <mailto:sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.org>>
        http://lists.sudoroom.org/____listinfo/sudo-discuss <http://lists.sudoroom.org/__listinfo/sudo-discuss>
        <http://lists.sudoroom.org/__listinfo/sudo-discuss <http://lists.sudoroom.org/listinfo/sudo-discuss>>

        ___________________________________________________ sudo-discuss
        mailing list sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.____org
        <mailto:sudo-discuss@lists.__sudoroom.org <mailto:sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.org>>
        http://lists.sudoroom.org/____listinfo/sudo-discuss <http://lists.sudoroom.org/__listinfo/sudo-discuss>
_______________________________________________
sudo-discuss mailing list
sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.org
http://lists.sudoroom.org/listinfo/sudo-discuss



_______________________________________________
sudo-discuss mailing list
sudo-discuss@lists.sudoroom.org
http://lists.sudoroom.org/listinfo/sudo-discuss